WINNER Thanksgiving 2025

WINNER Holiday

WINNER Thanksgiving 2025

Gather your loved ones and let WINNER handle the Thanksgiving table this year. From classic turkey cuts and butcher favorites to seasonal sides, comforting pies, and sweet treats, our kitchen has everything you need — and maybe even a few delightful surprises.

Orders must by placed by Friday, November 21.

Pickups and deliveries will occur from Monday, November 24 through Wednesday, November 26.

Small Package with Maple Pecan Pie - $195

Small Package with Pumpkin Pie - $195

Small Package with Apple Crumble Pie - $195

Large Package with Maple Pecan Pie - $680

Large Package with Pumpkin Pie - $680

Large Package with Apple Crumble Pie - $680

Roast Boneless Turkey Breast — Whole Split Breast (2 lbs) - $92

Our slow-cooked boneless turkey breast. Does not include gravy.

GF, Contains: butter, garlic, thyme, bay leaf, lemon zest, salt, black pepper, sugar, juniper berries, rosemary, thyme, bay leaf, lemon, compound butter (butter, garlic, thyme, bay leaves, sage, rosemary)

Roast Boneless Turkey Breast — Half Split Breast (1 lb) - $46

Turkey Leg Confit — Whole, Drum, and Thigh on the Bone (2.25 lbs) - $87

Turkey leg, slow cooked in duck fat. Choose either a whole leg on the bone (drumstick and thigh), or a pint of pulled turkey meat in turkey jus (below). Does not include gravy.

GF DF, Contains: Turkey, salt, brown sugar, black pepper, maple syrup, bay leaf, thyme, carrots, celery, onion, shallots, apple, parsley, garlic, white sugar, juniper berries, rosemary, sage, thyme, bay leaf, lemon, duck fat

Turkey Leg Confit — 1 Pint of Pulled Meat in Jus - $23

Turkey leg, slow cooked in duck fat. A pint of pulled turkey meat in turkey jus. Does not include gravy.

GF DF, Contains: Turkey, salt, brown sugar, black pepper, maple syrup, bay leaf, thyme, carrots, celery, onion, shallots, apple, parsley, garlic, white sugar, juniper berries, rosemary, sage, thyme, bay leaf, lemon, duck fat

Sourdough Stuffing (16 oz) - $20

Serves 2

Contains: WINNER's sourdough bread, our homemade stock (roasted turkey & chicken bones, carrot, celery, onion, herbs, white wine), carrots, celery, onions, fennel, white pepper, celery seed, salt, tarragon, dill, parsley, chive, shallot, whole grain mustard, lemon zest, butter, olive oil

Mashed Potatoes (16 oz) - $16

Serves 2

GF, Contains: Potatoes, butter, cream, milk, vegetable oil, garlic, thyme, salt

Mac & Cheese (16 oz) - $18

Serves 2

Contains: cavatappi pasta, sharp cheddar, gruyere, confit garlic, butter, milk, heavy cream, wheat flour, salt, white pepper, egg

Roasted Brussels Sprouts (16 oz) - $19

Serves 2

Contains: Brussels sprouts, hazelnuts, salt, black pepper, vegetable oil, Vinaigrette contains maple syrup, grainy mustard, sherry vinegar, salt, pepper, olive oil, Hazelnuts and the vinaigrette are served on side.

Roasted Brussels Sprouts with Bacon (16 oz) - $25

Serves 2

Contains: bacon, Brussels sprouts, hazelnuts, salt, black pepper, vegetable oil, Vinaigrette contains maple syrup, grainy mustard, sherry vinegar, salt, pepper, olive oil, Hazelnuts and the vinaigrette are served on side.

Gravy (16 oz) - $23

Contains: Roasted turkey and chicken bones, carrot, celery, onions, herbs, white wine, vegetable oil, wheat flour, butter, salt, black pepper

Gluten-Free Gravy (16 oz) - $23

GF, Contains: Roasted turkey and chicken bones, carrot, celery, onions, herbs, white wine, vegetable oil, butter, salt, black pepper

Cranberry Sauce (16 oz) - $23

Serves 2

GF DF Vegan, Contains cranberries, white sugar, vanilla beans, cinnamon, star anise, thyme, ginger, orange juice & zest, salt

Sourdough Baguette (1 loaf) - $6

Our baguettes adhere to traditional French ideals and mix natural leavening with commercial yeast for a quick loaf with complex flavor. We use a mix of high-protein bread flour and whole wheat flour to create a crispy crust and an open crumb structure. We add a touch of malted barley syrup to enhance the sweetness of the flour and give a deeper flavor.

Sourdough Bread (1 loaf) - $10

Our sourdough loaves are 100% naturally leavened. We use a mix of bread flour, whole wheat flour and rye flour. All of the flour we use in our sourdough loaves is organic and from Artisan’s Baker’s Craft in Utah. We cold-ferment our sourdough loaves after hand-shaping for 18-24 hours.

Vegan, Contains: 15% whole wheat flour, 5% rye flour, bread flour, salt, water, sourdough starter

Brioche Rolls (4 pack) - $8

Serves 4

The perfect roll for sopping up gravy and making a fantastic turkey sandwich the day after Thanksgiving

Contains: wheat flour, starter, yeast, salt, sugar and butter

10-12 lb Whole - $84

Serves 10-12

10-12 lb Spatchcocked - $109

Serves 10-12

10-12 lb Quartered - $114

Serves 10-12

12-14 lb Whole - $96

Serves 12-14

12-14 lb Spatchcocked - $121

Serves 12-14

12-14 lb Quartered - $126

Serves 12-14

14-16 lb Whole - $110

Serves 14-16

14-16 lb Spatchcocked - $135

Serves 14-16

14-16 lb Quartered - $140

Serves 14-16

16-18 lb Whole - $124

Serves 16-18

16-18 lb Spatchcocked - $149

Serves 16-18

16-18 lb Quartered - $154

Serves 16-18

18-20 lb Whole - $138

Serves 18-20

18-20 lb Spatchcocked - $163

Serves 18-20

18-20 lb Quartered - $168

Serves 18-20

10-12 lb Whole - $192

Serves 10-12

10-12 lb Spatchcocked - $217

Serves 10-12

10-12 lb Quartered - $222

Serves 10-12

12-14 lb Whole - $224

Serves 12-14

12-14 lb Spatchcocked - $249

Serves 12-14

12-14 lb Quartered - $254

Serves 12-14

14-16 lb Whole - $256

Serves 14-16

14-16 lb Spatchcocked - $281

Serves 14-16

14-16 lb Quartered - $286

Serves 14-16

16-18 lb Whole - $288

Serves 16-18

16-18 lb Spatchcocked - $313

Serves 16-18

16-18 lb Quartered - $318

Serves 16-18

18-20 lb Whole - $320

Serves 18-20

18-20 lb Spatchcocked - $345

Serves 18-20

18-20 lb Quartered - $350

Serves 18-20

Boneless Turkey Breast Roast (Uncooked) (2.5-3 lbs) - $40

Serves 4 - 6

Boneless turkey breast roast with skin on, netted and ready to roast. Pasture-raised turkey (no antibiotics) from Stryker Farm in PA.

Whole Turkey Breast Crown Roast (Uncooked) (6-8 lbs) - $96

Serves 8 - 10

Whole turkey breast roast with skin on, on the bone. Pasture-raised turkey, no antibiotics from Stryker Farm in PA.

Split Turkey Breast on the Bone (Uncooked) - $48

Serves 4 - 6

Whole Turkey Leg On The Bone (Uncooked) (2-2.5 lbs) - $16

Serves 2 - 3

Turkey Drumstick (Uncooked) (0.75-1 lb) - $8

Serves 1

Turkey Thigh (Uncooked) - $8

Serves 1

Turkey Brining Kit - $15

A WINNER brine dry mix that can be used to wet brine or dry brine your turkey, a large brining bag, butcher twine, and instructions on both wet- and dry-brining your turkey. Plan at least one day for brining your turkey before roasting.

Turkey Brining Bag - $5

19"W x 24.5"H. Twist tie closure. 25 lb capacity.

Foil Roasting Pan - $5

18" x 14" x 3" oval foil roast pan for turkey and large-roast cooking

Beef Tenderloin (Two 8oz medallions) - $40

Serves 2

Beef tenderloin (also called filet mignon) from the pasture-raised cattle at Happy Valley.

Beef Tenderloin (4.5-5 lbs average) - $200

Serves 8 - 10

Tied with butcher's twine to ensure even cooking

Standing Beef Rib Roast (Two bone beef rib roast, avg. 3.75 lbs) - $125

Serves 3-4

Hinged, tied, and frenched for easy cooking, carving, and serving from the pasture-raised cattle at Happy Valley.

Hinged & tied means we loosen the meat from the bones and tie it back on. Frenched means we clean the ends of the rib bones for a neat, classic look. After roasting, cut the twine and the meat will come away easily from the bone.

Standing Beef Rib Roast (Three bone beef rib roast, avg. 5.75 lbs) - $180

Serves 4-6

Hinged, tied, and frenched for easy cooking, carving, and serving from the pasture-raised cattle at Happy Valley.

Hinged & tied means we loosen the meat from the bones and tie it back on. Frenched means we clean the ends of the rib bones for a neat, classic look. After roasting, cut the twine and the meat will come away easily from the bone.

Standing Beef Rib Roast (Four bone beef rib roast, avg. 7.75 lbs) - $260

Serves 6-8

Hinged, tied, and frenched for easy cooking, carving, and serving from the pasture-raised cattle at Happy Valley.

Hinged & tied means we loosen the meat from the bones and tie it back on. Frenched means we clean the ends of the rib bones for a neat, classic look. After roasting, cut the twine and the meat will come away easily from the bone.

Standing Beef Rib Roast (Five bone beef rib roast, avg. 9.5 lbs) - $320

Serves 8-10

Hinged, tied, and frenched for easy cooking, carving, and serving from the pasture-raised cattle at Happy Valley.

Hinged & tied means we loosen the meat from the bones and tie it back on. Frenched means we clean the ends of the rib bones for a neat, classic look. After roasting, cut the twine and the meat will come away easily from the bone.

Standing Beef Rib Roast (Six bone beef rib roast, avg. 11.5 lbs) - $390

Serves 10-12

Hinged, tied, and frenched for easy cooking, carving, and serving from the pasture-raised cattle at Happy Valley.

Hinged & tied means we loosen the meat from the bones and tie it back on. Frenched means we clean the ends of the rib bones for a neat, classic look. After roasting, cut the twine and the meat will come away easily from the bone.

Standing Beef Rib Roast (Seven bone beef rib roast, avg. 13.5 lbs) - $455

Serves 12-14

Hinged, tied, and frenched for easy cooking, carving, and serving from the pasture-raised cattle at Happy Valley.

Hinged & tied means we loosen the meat from the bones and tie it back on. Frenched means we clean the ends of the rib bones for a neat, classic look. After roasting, cut the twine and the meat will come away easily from the bone.

Maple Glazed Ham — Whole (8 lbs) - $160

Serves 12-16

Our fully-cooked, smoked maple ham is ready for glazing and reheating. Plan on 1/3 to 1/2 lb per person—or more for heartier appetites. Ham glaze comes on the side.

Glaze contains: Maple syrup, brown sugar, salt, dijon mustard, apple cider vinegar, and butter.

Maple Glazed Ham — Half (4 lbs) - $80

Serves 6-8

Our fully-cooked, smoked maple ham is ready for glazing and reheating. Plan on 1/3 to 1/2 lb per person—or more for heartier appetites. Ham glaze comes on the side.

Glaze contains: Maple syrup, brown sugar, salt, dijon mustard, apple cider vinegar, and butter.

Maple Glazed Ham — Quarter (2 lbs) - $40

Serves 2-4

Our fully-cooked, smoked maple ham is ready for glazing and reheating. Plan on 1/3 to 1/2 lb per person—or more for heartier appetites. Ham glaze comes on the side.

Glaze contains: Maple syrup, brown sugar, salt, dijon mustard, apple cider vinegar, and butter.

Pork Belly Porchetta (2 lb) - $48

Serves 2-4 (Estimate 1/3 - 1/2 lb per person)

Fully-cooked and ready to eat, from Stryker Farms in PA. Just crisp the skin in the oven.

Contains: Pork Belly, Salt, Brown Sugar, Black Pepper, Coriander, Fennel, Lemon Zest, Parsley, Garlic, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Pork Belly Porchetta (4 lb) - $96

Serves 6-8

Fully-cooked and ready to eat, from Stryker Farms in PA. Just crisp the skin in the oven.

Contains: Pork Belly, Salt, Brown Sugar, Black Pepper, Coriander, Fennel, Lemon Zest, Parsley, Garlic, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Pork Belly Porchetta (6 lb) - $144

Serves 8-10

Fully-cooked and ready to eat, from Stryker Farms in PA. Just crisp the skin in the oven.

Contains: Pork Belly, Salt, Brown Sugar, Black Pepper, Coriander, Fennel, Lemon Zest, Parsley, Garlic, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Pork Sage Sausage (1 lb) - $13

1 lb of our house-made loose (uncased) sage sausage for your stuffing, or breakfast patties on Thanksgiving morning! Sausage is uncooked.

Contains: pork, salt, white sugar, dried sage, nutmeg

Maple Breakfast Pork Sausage (6 links) - $12

6 links of our house-made Maple Breakfast Pork Sausage, uncooked

Contains: lamb casing, pork, salt, white sugar, dried sage, nutmeg, and maple syrup

Maple Bacon (1 lb. sliced bacon) - $18

Our thick sliced house-made Pasture Raised Pork Maple Bacon

Contains: pork, salt, white sugar, pink salt #1, maple syrup

Whole Heritage Chicken (avg. 3.75 lb) - $34

Serves 4

From Snowdance Farm, these large heritage chickens have yellow skin, and are beautifully meaty & flavorful.

American Pekin Duck Breast (2 pieces) - $23

Serves 2

American Pekin Duck Legs (2 pieces) - $18

Serves 2

Maple Pecan Pie (9" Pie) - $45

Serves 8

Contains: dark brown sugar, maple syrup, glucose syrup, salt, butter, vanilla paste, lemon zest, eggs, pecans, pie dough (all purpose flour, butter, sugar, salt), dairy, tree nut, egg, wheat

Pumpkin Pie (9" Pie) - $45

Serves 8

Contains: pumpkin puree, eggs, heavy cream, creme fraiche, brown Sugar, salt, cinnamon, ginger, clove, nutmeg, pie dough (all purpose flour, butter, sugar, salt)

Apple Crumble Pie (9" Pie) - $45

Serves 8

Contains: apples, sugar, brown sugar, lemon juice, cornstarch, cinnamon, butter, oat crumble (AP flour, brown sugar, oats, salt, cinnamon, butter, vanilla), and pie dough (all purpose flour, butter, sugar, salt), milk, wheat, egg

Take-and-Bake Cinnamon Rolls (4 pieces) - $22

Serves 4

Raw and ready to proof & bake. Simply proof the rolls overnight, bake, and top with our cream cheese buttermilk glaze.

Contains: dough (all-purpose flour, malt flour, eggs, milk, sugar, malt syrup, instant yeast, salt, butter), filling (dark brown sugar, butter, cinnamon, salt), frosting (cream cheese, butter, confectioners sugar, lemon zest, buttermilk)

Small Pumpkin Olive Oil Loaf (Vegan) (1 loaf) - $15

Serves 2-4

Contains: sugar, pumpkin puree, oat milk, olive oil, vanilla paste, AP flour, salt, baking powder, cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, orange juice

Large Pumpkin Olive Oil Loaf (Vegan) (1 loaf) - $32

Serves 8-12

Contains: sugar, pumpkin puree, oat milk, olive oil, vanilla paste, AP flour, salt, baking powder, cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, orange juice

How would you like to receive your order?

Pickup at WINNER Butcher

192 5th Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11217

Pickup at Runner Up

499 11th Street
Brooklyn, NY 11215

Delivery - $15

See included map for delivery range!

Optional Gratuity

100% of gratuity goes directly to the team at WINNER who will help prepare your Thanksgiving goods!

10% 15% 18% Custom

Service Fee

All orders include a flat 10% service fee.